Why Do You Roast Meat But Bake A Cake?

Your recipe for roast loin of pork says to roast in a 350 degree oven. Your recipe for yellow butter cake says to bake in a 350 degree oven. For either recipe, you open the oven and put your food in. So, is there a difference between baking and roasting?

The short answer is “No.” But it really isn’t as simple as all that. Baking and roasting are both dry heat cooking methods. This just means that the food being cooked isn’t covered in a sauce or other liquid during the cooking process.

In modern times, we assume that baking and roasting both occur in ovens. Prior to having access to home ovens, people baked and roasted over a fire. Food was often roasted on a spit over flames either on the hearth or in an outdoor fire. A Dutch oven, made of heavy cast iron, was placed in the fire, covered, and coals were place on top of the lid. This provided radiant, if uneven, heat from all sides.

The Joy of Cooking defines roasting as a specialized type of baking. Roasting is almost always done in an open pan; that is, the food to be roasted is uncovered. Often, when roasting meat, you place it on a rack so it doesn’t sit in its own juices as it roasts. The rack serves as a suspension system whereby the meat is “suspended” in the oven over a pan (shades of spit roasting in days of yore).

There also seems to be a convention associated with the terms “bake” and “roast.” Although the two identify almost identical cooking techniques, in the modern kitchen anyway, “baking” is most generally associated with breads, cakes, pies and casseroles while “roasting” is what you do to meat or vegetables.

Roasting often starts at a higher temperature to create a “crust” on the outside of what is being roasted. Then, the temperature is reduced for the remainder of the cooking time. This is also the case when baking pate a choux (for cream puffs or éclairs) and some breads. In these similar cases, the identical cooking process (high temperature reducing to a lower temperature) is employed for different reasons.

In the roasting example, you’re trying to encourage exterior browning and caramelization of the target food before decreasing the heat and finishing gently. In the baking example, you need an initial burst of intense heat to encourage an expansion of air to make the pate a choux puff up or to encourage optimum oven-spring in the bread (the yeasts’ last hoorah). Then, the temperature is reduced to set and dry the structure of both the pate a choux and the bread.

So, while roasting and baking are almost identical methods of dry heat cooking, the terms roasting and baking apply to two different kinds of foods. You generally roast food that has structure already, solid foods such as meats and vegetables. You generally bake foods that don’t have much structure until they are baked: cakes, breads, pies, casseroles, crème brulee, etc.

Okay, so what about a baked potato, you ask? You’ve read the article; is it a baked potato…or a roasted one?