Does Alcohol In Wine Matter?
Wine Etiquette
by Chef Mark R. Vogel

The other day I was having a conversation with my neighbor Bill. Bill is an extremely good-natured and caring person. But he is also honest and straight-forward; a no BS kind of guy who holds no inhibitions about proclaiming the emperor isn’t wearing any clothes. He’ll tell you like it is.
In this nauseatingly, politically correct world where much communication is euphemized, or packaged in sensitivity-side-stepping disingenuousness, Bill’s candor is refreshing. We were discussing the trappings of the working world, particularly the suffocating level of tact and diplomacy required to survive interpersonally these days. Bill stated: “Do you know what etiquette is?” “What?” I queried. “It’s not stating the obvious.” I chuckled with empathic resonance.
I’ll bet some of you thought when you read the title of this article that it was going to be some hoity-toity, snobby list of rules for consuming wine. No Sir. I am fully embracing Bill’s definition of etiquette and applying it to wine. Only I’m going to be “anti-etiquette” and state the obvious.
What is this “obviousness” about wine that certain people don’t want to hear or deny? It’s this: Alcohol is a key factor in wine consumption. Crash! I can hear the Riedel crystal goblets falling to the floor as outraged connoisseurs become incensed at my suggestion that alcohol influences their appreciation of their beloved elixir. How boorish of me to cheapen their sophisticated epicureanism by suggesting it embraces some primitive strivings.
The oenophile would argue that wine, especially fine wine, is not an alcohol transmission device or a refreshment to be quaffed uncouthly in response to thirst or base impulses. On the simplest level, wine is about food and is therefore an inextricable component to all that food represents.
But wine is even more than the gustatory pleasure of uniting a painstakingly refined product with exquisite food. Wine is an icon of our culture and a symbol of our traditions. Its sociocultural roots are imbedded in our theology, our celebrations of life, and our respect for the land. Wine is transcendent and its study and appreciation are an urbane and profound endeavor.
I heartily agree with those sentiments but I don’t think that’s the whole story. First of all, if alcohol were removed from wine, it wouldn’t be wine. It would taste radically different. Alcohol is one of the primary constituents of wine, which in conjunction with tannins, fruit, and acidity form the wine’s structure.




When I was working as a Wall Street broker, I became interested in French wines, how to buy them and even started collecting some great 1985 Bordeaux wines to "lay down" so they would be perfect when I opened them 10 years later. One year I even had the opportunity to attend Kevin Zraly’s Windows On The World Wine School at the top of the World Trade Center. What an incredible experience.