What Does “Salt and Pepper, to Taste” mean?
Have you ever seen or heard the expression, salt and pepper to taste? I see it all the time in cookbooks and online recipes. In fact, I use this expression in my recipes.
But What Does It Mean?
I think it means different things to different people and that’s why I want to learn more about the expression. Some, but not many, recipes give you exact amounts of salt and pepper to add to a recipe but most don’t.
I’ve learned from cooking recipes developed by professional chefs to add salt and pepper several times during the cooking process. They don’t say add 1/4 teaspoon of salt and pepper, they just say season with salt and pepper.
Personally, I think “to taste” is different for both salt and pepper and it should read, salt – to taste and pepper – to taste. They both mean something different.
Salt to taste has more to do with adding the right amount of salt to bring out the flavors in the food. Pepper to taste deals with how much heat you want the dish to have.
So that’s what it means to me but I’m not sure what it means to other people including some professional chefs I know. So I asked a few of them for their definition and here is what I learned.
Salt should be used to bring out the natural flavor of foods, not to make them taste salty. The amount needed varies from food to food, because foods are produced differently.
For instance, a recipe for homemade tomato sauce may call for one teaspoon of salt. But if the tomatoes are under-ripe, the recipe will need more salt to bring out their natural tomato-i-ness. If the tomatoes are freshly picked at the height of the season, they may need very little salt, if any.
The season, the variety, the soil, and the accuracy of the cook all play a part in determining flavor. This is one reason I constantly urge people to see beyond the written recipe.
Pepper is a spice, and its use imparts heat and flavor. The amount of heat and pepper flavor you add is entirely based on how much you enjoy.
I only use pepper when its flavor will enhance a dish, which is nowhere near as much as it is called for in recipes. And for heat, I prefer white pepper, which packs a bigger bang for the buck.
As to “salt and pepper to taste,” that can be a hard thing, and it’s one that I struggled with for a long time as a home cook. I wish there were a definitive test for “correct seasoning,” but there really isn’t.
I will say that, since I’ve been cooking professionally, I use salt more than I used to. Before, I always put salt in everything, but just a little bit.
Now, I find that I salt more heavily. It doesn’t make my food saltier, it just makes it better.
Have you ever tasted a dish that’s a little–or a lot– “flat?” Chances are, it needs a lot more salt than it’s already got.
Try this: make any basic recipe that you like that doesn’t call for salt, or calls for the infamous “to taste.” Start without any salt in it at all and taste it.
Add 1/4 teaspoon of salt, stir, and taste again. You should be able to tell a difference.
Add another 1/4 teaspoon. Stir and taste. The flavors will begin to “pop” when your salting is correct.
To me the effect is more startling in a dessert, because people don’t generally think of using lots of salt in sweets. I did this test with vanilla pudding, but use whatever recipe you’d like. You’ll be able to taste more nuances in the dish and it will taste just more like what it is (more tomato-y, more chocolate-y, etc).
There will come a point when the “noticeably salty” stage is reached. The trick is to stop adding salt before that happens.
There can be a very thin line between perfectly seasoned and salty, and the trick is to come up to the line without going over. That takes practice and eating some overly salty food on occasion!
You know when chefs say to make the water you cook your veggies or pasta in taste like sea water? Most home cooks think that’s just too salty, but that’s because most home cooks under-salt.
Don’t get me wrong: you don’t want your spaghetti sauce to taste like sea water (I don’t think), but most dishes can handle, and benefit from, more salt than is called for or more than people think.
Again, it is a very subjective thing, so when you season, season to your taste. I know some chefs who refuse to put salt and pepper on the table, because what they’re sending out is already perfectly seasoned (to their taste, anyway). That’s pushing it a bit.
As for pepper, that is not as vital a seasoning as salt (I use tons of it at home when I make savory dishes). Salt enhances the flavors and can help bring subtleties of the dish into focus. Pepper makes things hot and tickles in the back of the throat a bit.
My advice is to focus on the salt, add a few grinds of pepper (always use freshly ground so you get the benefit of the essential oil in the pepper) and leave a pepper mill on the table.
Chef Martin Laprise
The idea is for you to learn to taste your food many times during the process to see what is happening. To taste, is what professional do, they taste all food before the clients.
So if there are issue, the cooks will find out before the clients. Salt is the number one thing that chef can control very well. Too much and it’s really bad, and not enough and that too is really bland and bad.
Chef Terrell Garret
I had to laugh with your question about what to ‘taste means’. It was one of the most asked questions at the so called free for all at graduation sessions at the culinary school.
The answer was to take a small portion of the dish being prepared and cook it, no matter what method and taste it for seasoning. Believe it or not, that usually worked.
Chef Daniel D’Angelo CEC AAC MS
Salt and pepper to taste means the taste to the palate of the person that is making it. If you look at recipes from maybe 20 years ago, they may have a weight to the recipes. As the years progressed, it was easier to write the meaning to taste.
When cooking with salt and pepper or any cooking for that matter, you must build on flavor and as you add flavors you keep changing and tasting until you like what you are making.
I asked this question to my daughter Nell back in 2010 when she was just 13 years old. She told me, “Salt and pepper, to taste means add the salt and pepper to your liking. For example, I might like more salt on my food then another person so I would add more salt to the dish.”
What Does Salt & Pepper, To Taste Mean to You?
I’ll keep asking my chef friends for their responses but please let me know in the comments section below what salt and pepper, to taste means to you. Thanks.