Barbecue Ribs – Doing Them Right

July 19, 2011 4 Comments

Barbecue Ribs

Shedding Some Light on Ribs

I wrote a post last week called What Is Barbecue about the different styles of barbecue.  There’s so much information out there on barbecue, but even after all my research, I probably just barely scratched the surface.  While the sheer amount of fact and opinion out there is daunting, I still want to make an amazing rack (or three) of Kansas City-style ribs for my family.

So, I dove back in to find some specific answers to my questions about making barbecued ribs.  Hopefully, this post will answer my questions about ribs like:

  • Do I really have to have a smoker?
  • Is it okay to wrap the ribs in foil?
  • What about baking?  Is that barbecue blasphemy?

And maybe it will answer more questions that you might have.  As a home amatur cook, I write these posts when I want to learn something new about a particular subject with the idea that you may have the same question. After all, we’re in this together.  Let’s learn about ribs

Rib Anatomy

Just like in humans, the ribs are attached at the spine and at the sternum, and form a cage that protects vital organs such as the heart and lungs.  In cross-section, portions of the rib cage form a circle, just like a real cage.

Ribs for barbecue can be cut from the back of the pig near its spine.  These are called baby back ribs or loin ribs, since they are cut from the back.  Aside from the loin, ribs are also cut from areas along the sides and belly of the pig, just up from the sternum.  These are called spare ribs.  Just two racks of baby backs and two racks of spare ribs can be cut from each pig.

How to Barbecue Ribs

But ribs are ribs, right?  They probably all taste the same?

This is absolutely false.  Baby back ribs are fairly small and curved, are leaner and more delicate in flavor.  Spare ribs are larger and flatter and contain a lot more fat.  Since fat carries flavor, spare ribs are often favored by barbecue experts due to their rich meaty flavor.

Many national chain restaurants serve baby back ribs because they are smaller and cook more quickly, but for real barbecue aficionados, and real barbecue restaurants, pork spare ribs are the ribs of choice.

Before you Texans start chiming in, yes, I know you can also barbecue beef ribs.  But for me, pork ribs not only give me that slightly sweet flavor that I love, they are also better suited size-wise to my family.  Beef ribs are huge and have a lot of meat. If you’re a big eater, or you’re from Texas, you can absolutely barbecue beef ribs rather than pork ribs; just remember that beef ribs will take longer to cook, so adjust your cooking time accordingly.

Different Styles of Ribs

The main difference among the different styles of ribs are whether or not a rub and/or mop and/or sauce is used and the way the ribs are trimmed.  For example, St. Louis-style ribs, the kind that I’m most interested in making, are spare ribs that have been trimmed of the brisket end and the skirt.

(If your eyes just started to glaze over, you’re not alone.  Mine did too when the butcher told me that.  Don’t worry, though–just ask the butcher to trim them for you.)

barbecue ribs

Cooking Ribs at Home

I don’t want you to think that you shouldn’t cook baby back ribs at home.  That’s the beauty of cooking at home; you can make pretty much anything you want!  Baby backs are a good choice if you want a quicker meal and less fatty ribs.  You can apply any of these cooking techniques to either baby back or spare ribs.

Before cooking, remove the tough membrane that runs along the length of the bony side of your rack of ribs.  This isn’t hard to do.  Just work your knife under the membrane along one of the short ends of your ribs.  Once you have about an inch of it loose, grab that end with a paper towel or a lint-free cloth towel and pull back and away.  The membrane should come off in one piece.  If it doesn’t, use your knife again to loosen up another little flap and then pull.

This is a necessary step in cooking ribs.  The membrane is impermeable.  That means that nothing gets through it.  If you leave the membrane in place, no matter how much rub you put on that side, no flavor is going to get through that membrane.

Smoke Then Grill

Probably the most authentic pit master way of cooking barbecue ribs is to smoke them first and then finish them on the grill.  Either season simply with some salt and pepper or pack on your favorite rub. (If using a rub, wrap the ribs in plastic wrap and let them rest in the refrigerator for up to 12 hours).

Once your ribs are seasoned to your liking, smoke them between 200-225F until you can rotate a rib bone slightly, about 4 hours, give or take, depending on how large your ribs are.  If you can’t rotate the bone, then the connective tissue has not broken down enough.

Once the bones are a bit loose inside the meat, you can finish them off on the grill over medium-high heat.  Now is the time to slather on your favorite barbecue sauce, unless you want to cook the ribs dry, or without sauce.  In that case, simply serve some sauce on the side, and make everyone happy.

You can also go ahead and eat the ribs as is, without grilling them.  Just baste on some sauce during the last 30 minutes of cooking. But, if you want some caramelization, you’re going to have to take them to the grill.

The ribs should only need a few minutes on the grill on each side.  Remember, they are already cooked from the smoking.  Grilling will add just a little bit of char and, if you are using sauce, the heat will caramelize the sauce and thicken it for a really finger licking, lip smacking barbecue.  There is a fair amount of sugar in most barbecue sauces, so watch carefully.  Sauced ribs can turn from succulent to carbonized in a very short amount of time!

One down-side of this method, especially if you are cooking baby back ribs, is that the meat can have a tendency to dry out.  Keep the heat in your smoker low and don’t let them overcook to help minimize the chance of dryness.

The 3-2-1 Method

This is an easy one to remember:  3 hours unwrapped in the smoker, 2 hours tightly wrapped in foil in the smoker, 1 more hour unwrapped.  The first three hours, you cook them meat side up, the next two, meat side down and the last, meat side up again.

With the 3-2-1 method, you are sure to end up with moist and tender ribs, because during the two hours the ribs are wrapped in foil, they are steaming in their own juices.  The times are specifically for spare ribs, so if you’re cooking baby back ribs, reduce the first time from 3 hours to 2.

What If I Don’t Have a Smoker?

You can turn your charcoal grill into a smoker if you will only be cooking 1 or 2 racks of ribs.  It’s pretty simple, really.  Aside from your normal grilling gear, you will need:

  • 2 disposable pans.  The 2 pans should be able to fit side by side in the grill with little or no room left over.
  • Some chunks of hardwood for smoking.

How to:

  1. Take the grilling rack off the grill and put one of the pans in one side of the bottom of your grill (on top of the small grate that holds the coals).
  2. Light the coals in the other half of the bottom of the grill.
  3. Once the coals are ready, add a few large chunks of hardwood to generate smoke.
  4. Replace the grilling rack and put the other pan directly over the coals.
  5. Fill the pan with boiling water.  This will keep the interior of your grill, and the ribs, moist.
  6. Place your seasoned ribs over the empty pan and next to the pan of water.  The pan underneath will catch any drips and keep the charcoal over on the other side of the grill.
  7. Put the lid on the grill and adjust the heat using the damper to keep the temperature around 215-225F.
  8. You can use the 3-2-1 method or the smoke-then-grill method.  You will probably have to replace the hardwood chunks every hour or so to make sure it stays good and smoky, at least during the first couple of hours of cooking when most of the smoke penetration happens.

But I Don’t Have Time for All That

Six hours is a huge time commitment.  And making your own smoker might seem like growing your own mustard plants so you can make some Dijon to go on your ham!  Granted, you don’t need to be standing right over the smoker the whole time, and your neighbors will spend most of the day salivating over the amazing smells coming from your back yard, but as much as I like to do things the authentic way, sometimes I just don’t have the time.  So then what?

Using your oven won’t give you the traditional smoke flavor, but it will shave a few hours off of prep time, and you can always add just a touch of liquid smoke to your marinade.

  • The night before, or at least 2 hours before cooking, remove the rib membrane and season with your favorite rub or with just salt and pepper.  Preheat the oven to 250F.
  • Mix up some barbecue sauce or thin out a store-bought sauce with a bit of beer, stock or water to use as a marinade.
  • Wrap the ribs up in foil, leaving one end open.  Carefully pour in about a cup of your marinade and tightly seal the opening.
  • Place the ribs on a baking sheet and bake for about 2 1/2 hours, or until you can just rotate one of the rib bones.
  • Pour the marinade and drippings into a pan and reduce until syrupy.
  • Serve this as a sauce for your ribs.

Crock Pot Ribs

This is an unconventional method of cooking ribs, and I can almost guarantee you that you will never find this at your local barbecue shack, but you can’t beat this method for walk-away ease and tender, fall-off-the-bone ribs.

  • In the morning before you go out for the day, dice up a large onion and put it in the bottom of your crock pot.
  • Put the ribs in on top (you might have to cut the rack in half or thirds, depending on the size of your crock pot).
  • Then, pour in 1 1/2 cups of store bought or homemade barbecue sauce, put on the lid and turn the crock pot to medium.
  • If your crock pot doesn’t have a medium setting, turn it to high.

The ribs will be done in 6-8 hours.  They won’t be the kind you can pick up and gnaw off the bone.  As a matter of fact, the meat will probably fall off the bones while you’re trying to get them out of the crock pot!

Bert’s Barbecue Baby Back Ribs

Purists would say Bert’s method isn’t barbecue at all but if you are in a hurry and want some delicious steamed/grilled ribs, this is a great alternative. I have made these ribs many times on weeknights when I don’t have 3 hours to slow cook with smoke.

In Bert’s method, ribs are seasoned and cooked covered with the contents of a bottle of a beer. In the past I have said they are braised, but looking at it more closely, I would say the ribs are steamed and not braised because of the amount of liquid used in the cooking process. To read my post on this process, check out Bert’s Barbecue Baby Back Ribs.

Bottom Line

The bottom line is that you’re never going to have really moist, tender “barbecue” ribs in under 2 1/2-3 hours.  Ribs have a lot of connective tissue, and low, slow moist cooking is absolutely necessary to make the collagen break down into gelatin without having the proteins seize up like they would at high temperatures. Yes, you can braise/steam first and grill second and even use a little smoke, but is that really barbecue. I guess it depends on where you are from and what you grew up with.

Last modified on Thu 31 July 2014 11:05 am

Comments (4)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. LADawg says:

    Everything we needed to know about ribs, but were afraid to ask. I like a dry rib and here is the recipe for my dry rub.


    4 Teaspoons Hungarian Paprika
    1 Teaspoon Salt
    2 Teaspoons Onion Powder
    1 Teaspoon Garlic Powder
    2 Teaspoons Black Pepper
    1 Teaspoons White Pepper
    1 1/2 Teaspoons Dry Mustard
    1 1/2 Teaspoons Granulated Brown Sugar

    Add all ingredients to a 16 ounce jar with a lid. Close lid and shake well until all ingredients are well blended. If for some reason you use regular Brown Sugar, rather that the Granulated type, make sure that it is broken up and it is mixed well with the other ingredients. Stored in a lidded glass container for several weeks at room temperature.

  2. JImG says:

    Another alternative prep time saver is to put the ribs in a pressure cooker with a bit of beer for 40 minutes or so, then finish them on the grill. Tender and tasty.

  3. Lucia says:

    The egg-shaped ceramic grill is safe, from the lid all the way to the smoke.

    I highly suggest this unique and powerful Napoleon Prestige Gas
    Grill for all consumers. As for smoking salmon at home, it’s really not that difficult.

Leave a Reply