How To Boil Water
As a cooking technique, how to boil foods doesn't get the same respect today as it did when I was growing up. Back in the day, my mom boiled everything and often.
The problem was she only knew one kind of boil and that was a vigorous boil, what we now call a "Full Boil" that often resulted in overcooked, soggy, limp food.
Today I still use a full boil for cooking pasta and hard boiled eggs or to blanch vegetables but I also use other boiling techniques like "slow boil", "poach" and "simmer". You may think boiling only occurs at 212°F but it really has a lot to do with the atmospheric pressure around you.
For example, when we lived in Park City, Utah at higher elevations with lower atmosphere pressure, the boiling point was lower but we had to increase the cooking times because the food was cooking at a lower temperature.
A Little Boiling Science
In scientific terms, boiling occurs when the vapor pressure of a liquid is equal to the atmospheric pressure. That sure clears things up, huh?
In everyday terminology, when water is heated, it turns to vapor. Boiling occurs when bubbles of vapor escape liquid by moving fast enough to break the surface of the liquid and through the surrounding air pressure—like Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator: “Must go faster if we’re going to break through!”
And you remember how that ended: CRASH!
Boiling is a pretty violent action. It’s an explosive phase change between a liquid state and a gas state. Anything delicate, like say, food, that gets in the way of this process can end up getting damaged.
Julia's Seven Stages of Heating Water
Boiling isn’t quite as black and white as that, however. As water is heated, it goes through several stages, first identified (or at least written down for culinary purposes) by Julia Child in From Julia Child’s Kitchen.
Tepid - 85°F to 105°F Tepid is not a useful temperature for cooking, but tepid water has its uses. You can immerse eggs in tepid water to gently bring up their temperature before using in recipes
Warm - 115°F to 120°F Warm water is used to activate yeast.
Hot - 130°F to 135°F Not hot enough to cook, but hot enough that you don’t want to put your hand in it.
Poach - 180°F to 190°F If you’ll notice, there is quite a gap between “hot” and “poach” according to Julia Child. I will be audacious enough to differ with her. It is possible to poach at temperatures as low as 140°F, as this is the low end of the scale at which proteins start to coagulate. If you want to poach a fish to an internal temperature of 140°F, the gentlest (although not quickest) way is to have the poaching liquid at 140°F. I’m sorry, Julia, but I think that poaching at 190°F might as well be a simmer.
Simmer - 190°F to 200°F The simmer. Most stews and braises are accomplished at this relatively low temperature. Gentle bubbling occurs, and the simmering liquid flavors the simmering food as the food flavors the liquid.
Slow Boil - 205°F A slow boil is a lazy boil, and is not too much different from a simmer. Bubbles will slowly break over the entire surface of the water.
Full Boil - 212°F A full boil is a vigorous boil with bubbles rapidly and violently breaking over the entire surface of the water.
While it is good to be aware of the seven stages of heating water, it is not quite as important, in most cases, to be a stickler for the temperatures at which most of these stages happen. One person’s “hot” might be another person’s “very warm,” and as I pointed out, one person’s “poach” might be another person’s “simmer.”
Use these stages as guidelines only. The temperatures are given for water only. Depending on the liquid, the boiling point could be reached at a higher or lower temperature. The further addition of salt and other flavorings affects the boiling point, as well.
Generally speaking, there are very few foods that I advocate cooking at a full rolling boil. Most moist heat cooking methods occur between temperatures of 140°F to 200°F, steaming being the one exception, at 212°F. Although steaming occurs at the boiling point, it is a much gentler cooking method since food is not immersed in boiling water. Rather, it is cooked by the heat of the rising water vapor. Another point to consider is nutrition.
Many water soluble vitamins can leach out into the cooking liquid during the boiling process. If you drain away your boiling liquid, you are throwing away a lot of nutrients. If possible, serve the cooking liquid as part of the dish to maintain the foods’ nutritional value.
Because of the violent nature of the full boil and the potential loss of nutrients, there are only a few foods I think should be cooked at a full, rolling boil. One of them is dried pasta. Fresh pasta may be too delicate to be cooked above a slow boil.
Cooking In Liquid or As Some Say Moist Heat Cooking Techniques
Rather than saying boiling techniques, let's call it cooking in liquids or moist heat cooking. The difference between poaching and simmering & simmering and full boil are only a matter of a few degrees but those few degrees make a big difference.
Personally, I would say simmering is not boiling although by definition, small bubbles do rise to the top and break the surface but it is very important to know the difference between a simmer and slow boil because each can have a dramatic effect on what you are cooking. Can you imagine if a recipe said to simmer a sauce for 10 minutes to reduce it but instead you cooked it at full boil? What a disaster you would have!
We'll look at each of these Moist Heat Cooking Techniques and see where and how you should use them. I'll start working on a chart to show the differences but you can start by reading my post on Poaching.
You may also want to take a look at How to Blanch Foods, a two-step process for cooking foods.
Another moist heat cooking technique is stewing and I have an informative article on How to Make a Great Stew Recipe that you may find helpful.
And of course you are going to want to check out my post on How to Cook Pasta to demonstrate the Full Boil technique.