How Do I Know When Shrimp Are Perfectly Cooked & Ready to Eat?
There are many ways to cook and serve shrimp. Do you remember Pvt. Benjamin Buford’s line in Forest Gump?
Anyway, like I was sayin', shrimp is the fruit of the sea. You can barbecue it, boil it, broil it, bake it, sauté it. Dey's uh, shrimp-kabobs, shrimp creole, shrimp gumbo. Pan fried, deep fried, stir-fried. There's pineapple shrimp, lemon shrimp, coconut shrimp, pepper shrimp, shrimp soup, shrimp stew, shrimp salad, shrimp and potatoes, shrimp burger, shrimp sandwich. That- that's about it.
What Pvt. Buford doesn’t tell you is how to know when shrimp are done cooking and need to be removed from the heat so they don’t overcook. Shrimp are one of those versatile ingredients that are easy to feature in a meal because of their simple sweet flavor, speed of cooking and compatibility with so many other ingredients.
Whether you are creating a shrimp Creole, stir-fry, seafood pasta dish, simple “shrimp on the barbie”, or one of the other hundreds of ways to serve shrimp, the most important thing to remember is not to overcook them. We’ve all done it and end up with a hard, rubbery texture that is OK to eat, just not that OK.
You really notice overcooked shrimp in a shrimp cocktail. You can bury over-cooked shrimp in a spicy tomato sauce or cream based French sauce but when it’s just a shrimp and some cocktail sauce, you know immediately something’s not right.
That’s why it is so important to know when shrimp are done cooking and ready to serve.
How Do You Know When Shrimp Are Done?
There are several methods for judging when shrimp are properly cooked. Is one method better than another? I’ll let you test them all and decide for yourself.
From SeaPak Shrimp & Seafood Company - These guys have been around and selling shrimp for over 60 years so I’m taking their word they know what they’re talking about.
They say, “Shrimp should be cooked to an internal temperature of 165 ºF. They will become an opaque whitish color when fully cooked.”
I’m not sure many of us are going to pull out our instant thermometers when grilling or pan frying shrimp but it’s an option. The change in color is how I learned from a cookbook early on and how I’ve been testing for shrimp doneness for years.
Raw shrimp start out with gray shells and translucent flesh which according to Webster’s Dictionary means, “permitting the passage of light: a) clear, transparent; b) transmitting and diffusing light so that objects beyond cannot be seen clearly.”
When properly cooked, the exterior should be pink with red tails and the flesh is slightly opaque and a little “white” in color. Here’s where it gets confusing because a “little white” may vary from cook to cook. If it is bright white in color, there’s a good chance the shrimp are overcooked.
I have been cooking shrimp this way for as long as I can remember and still find it difficult to nail it just right especially when you have to take into consideration the shrimp will continue to cook after removing from the heat unless you cool them off in an ice bath. While researching for this article I learned another way to tell when the shrimp are done that looks promising.
Raw shrimp (previously frozen) start out with just a little curl to their shape. I wouldn’t call them straight but with just a little pressure, you can straighten them out. When you cook shrimp, they naturally start to curl.
According to what I’ve recently learned, when they form a C-shape, they are perfectly cooked. However, if you let them continue to cook, they will twist into an O-shape signifying they are overcooked.
An easy way to remember this is C-shaped stands for “cooked” and O-shaped stands for “overcooked”.
This looks like a promising technique for telling when shrimp are cooked to perfection but what if you have them on skewers for shrimp kabob? The shrimp aren’t going to curl any because of the skewer so I’d suggest you go back to the Color technique and over time resort to my last technique….
The more you cook shrimp or any ingredient for that matter, the more you’ll being able to tell when something is done, by experience. Not only using all your senses including sight, touch, smell or even hearing but a feeling of “just knowing” when something is done.
This technique comes with time and lots of experience. The more you cook shrimp using the techniques above, the sooner you’ll be able to “just know” when it feels like it’s done and ready to plate. I pay attention to this feeling every time I cook and sometimes get it right and sometimes wrong knowing I’ll be better next time.
Shells On or Off - Cooking time is longer with shell on so you have to adjust cooking time accordingly. In my opinion leaving the shells on helps retain flavor and moisture but shell on or off really depends on the dish.
If I’m adding shrimp to a pasta or rice dish, I’ll usually remove the peels but if I’m serving a bowl of seasoned boiled or steamed shrimp, I like to leave the shells on.
Size - The size of the shrimp will affect how long they take to cook but if you use the techniques above, you should be able to get great results. Remember, the smaller shrimp will cook much faster so you really need to keep an eye on them.
Heat - I find shrimp does better with a higher heat cooking methods like grilling or pan frying. When I slow cook shrimp in a braise or crock pot recipe, it’s almost impossible to keep the shrimp from overcooking unless you add them right at the end. Same with a shrimp risotto. The shrimp is the last ingredient to be added so it can cook from the heat of the risotto and it doesn’t take long.
Thanks for the tips. I especially like the "C" is for cooked, "O" is for overcooked. I will see how this one works out. I usually use the look and see method coupled with experience over time. Like you, sometimes I get it wrong, and sometimes right. I love shrimps!
The Reluctant Gourmet
Let me know how it works out for you Alicia.
I cooked shrimp for the very first time last night, I've really only experienced shrimp from the shrimp cocktail kits I've bought at Walmart, For me and my husband, our new years resolution is to try more seafood. I broiled my shrimp for at least 4 minutes on each side, and later discovered that I had left the "peels" on but it still felt as if they were raw, it was pink, but the texture seemed off. I'm not sure if it is from my lack of experience with shrimp or if I actually under cooked it. Help please?
Didn’t help me any
I just wanted to know if my very small shrimp is suppose to be white, I use it to make easy shrimp scampi.
I just sent back my fried shrimp for something else. I’m at a restaurant and their fairly small. When I bit into my first shrimp I looked at it. It was translucent (all gray or “clear”. No white. ) and the texture was that of raw fish. I sent it back once to be cooked more. When the shrimp came back without improvement I returned the dish to it to the waitress. Am I wrong? Was the shrimp cooked? I have been hospitalized with food poisoning once and take great care not to ever repeat that experience.
G. Stephen Jones
Janet, it doesn't sound like it was cooked properly but hard to tell without seeing it. I'm guessing that will be the last visit to that restaurant.
Any idea of the cook time for shrimp in a pressure cooker? With a frozen lobster tail, shell down, meat up, it takes 3 minutes on low pressure with a quick release of pressure at the end of 3 minutes. This is with the lobster in a steam pot sitting above the water using a stove top pressure cooker.
How can you tell if the Shrimp is fried, when it’s done if it has no shell on it
Very worthwhile article, to the point and we’ll writen thank you. I’ll I’never forget again C not O thanks
I guess I like my shrimp a little over cooked: solid white in color. But, the last few times I've cooked shrimp (by boiling them), they never get to that stage no matter how long I cook them. What am I doing wrong?
When boiling shrimp bring water to boil put in shrimp when comes back to boil take them off they are done
Why are my prawns still translucent after they're cooked?